When a car accident occurs on private property, the legal and insurance implications differ significantly from those of a collision on public roads. Many drivers assume the same rules apply, but private property accidents—such as those in parking lots, driveways, or private neighborhoods—fall under distinct legal frameworks. Unlike public roadways,...
The Types of Damages Recoverable In St. Louis Car Accident
A car accident in St. Louis doesn't just leave you with a damaged vehicle—it can derail your health, finances, and future in ways insurance companies hope you'll never discover. Missouri's legal system recognizes multiple categories of damages, but insurers systematically undervalue or outright deny legitimate claims unless challenged by an experienced attorney. From the obvious medical expenses to the often-overlooked loss of life's simple pleasures, understanding the full spectrum of recoverable damages could mean the difference between financial recovery and lifelong hardship. This guide doesn't just list damage types—it reveals how St. Louis courts actually calculate them and the evidence needed to prove each element. Whether your crash happened on I-64 during rush hour or at a quiet Kirkwood intersection, these insights will help you fight for what Missouri law truly allows.
Medical Expenses: More Than Just Hospital Bills
While emergency room costs and surgery bills form the foundation of medical damage claims, St. Louis plaintiffs often miss reimbursable expenses like:
Medical mileage at the IRS rate (67 cents per mile in 2024)
Home healthcare services for temporary disabilities
Prescription medication co-pays and delivery fees
Future medical costs projected by life care planners
Surprisingly, Missouri allows recovery for alternative treatments (chiropractic, acupuncture) if a physician recommends them, but insurers routinely deny these without attorney intervention. Always keep a dedicated medical expense journal—courts favor contemporaneous records over reconstructed estimates.
Lost Wages: Calculating What You Would Have Earned
Missouri law permits compensation for both current lost paychecks and diminished future earning capacity, but proving the latter requires expert testimony. An economist can project:
Lost promotions due to recovery time
Reduced work hours from permanent disabilities
Career changes forced by physical limitations
The key is comparing pre-accident tax returns with post-accight vocational assessments. Beware—insurers illegally deduct taxes from lost wage claims; Missouri prohibits this under the collateral source rule.
Pain and Suffering: Quantifying the Unquantifiable
St. Louis juries calculate pain and suffering damages using either the "per diem" (daily rate) or "lump sum" method, but savvy attorneys employ psychological tactics:
Pain journals with daily symptom tracking
Family testimony about personality changes
Before/after videos showing mobility differences
Recent Missouri verdicts show juries award 1.5-5x medical specials for pain—higher for visible scars or permanent disabilities.
Property Damage: Hidden Costs in Vehicle Repairs
Beyond repair bills, you can recover:
Diminished value (even on properly repaired vehicles)
Rental car costs during repairs
Custom equipment replacement (wheelchair lifts, etc.)
Storage fees if the car is undriveable
Always get a diminished value appraisal from a certified specialist—dealership estimates are notoriously low.
Emotional Distress: When the Mind Suffers Too
Missouri recognizes standalone emotional distress claims for:
PTSD diagnosed by a psychiatrist
Travel anxiety preventing driving
Sleep disorders from crash memories
Documentation is key—insurers will argue these are "unproven" without therapy records and DSM-5 diagnoses.
Loss of Consortium: The Spouse's Claim
When injuries affect marital relationships, spouses can recover for:
Lost intimacy
Increased household burdens
Counseling costs
These damages require tactful presentation—detailed enough to prove harm, but not so graphic as to alienate jurors.
Punitive Damages: Rare But Powerful
In cases of drunk driving or extreme recklessness, Missouri permits punitive damages to punish wrongdoing. The legal standard requires:
Conscious disregard for safety
Similar prior incidents
Corporate cover-ups (for commercial vehicle cases
Punitive awards are capped at 5x compensatory damages or $500,000, whichever is greater.
Disfigurement: Life-Altering Scars
Facial scars or amputations warrant separate compensation because:
They affect social interactions
May require future revision surgeries
Can limit employment opportunities
Plastic surgeons provide crucial testimony on scar permanence and treatment costs.
Loss of Enjoyment: What You Can No Longer Do
This often-overlooked damage covers:
Hobbies made impossible (gardening, sports)
Missed family events
Inability to perform simple joys (picking up grandchildren)
Creative attorneys use lifestyle affidavits from friends and activity logs to prove these losses.
Wrongful Death Damages: When the Unthinkable Happens
Missouri wrongful death statutes allow:
Funeral/burial expenses
Lost financial support
Grief counseling for survivors
Loss of guidance for children
The statute of limitations is three years, but preserving evidence immediately is critical.
Future Medical Costs: Protecting Tomorrow's Health
Life care planners project expenses for:
Ongoing physical therapy
Assistive devices
Home modifications
Prescription regimens
These must account for inflation and regional cost differences—St. Louis rates differ from rural Missouri.
Loss of Services: The Household Impact
When injuries prevent normal household contributions, recover:
Lawn care/snow removal costs
Childcare expenses
Meal delivery services
Receipts are essential—verbal estimates won't suffice.
Interest on Damages: Missouri's Hidden Asset
Pre-judgment interest accrues at 9% annually from the date of loss—a substantial sum in delayed cases. Post-judgment interest runs at the statutory rate, currently 5.25%.
Nursing Care: The Overlooked Expense
Even temporary in-home nursing after surgery can cost $25-$50/hour—insurers will resist paying without:
Doctor's orders
Detailed care logs
Licensed provider invoices
Vocational Retraining: When You Can't Return
For career-ending injuries, courts award:
Tuition for new education
Certification program costs
Job placement services
Vocational experts prove these are necessary, not elective.
Witness Fees and Court Costs
Missouri lets prevailing plaintiffs recover:
Expert witness fees
Filing fees
Deposition transcript costs
These add up quickly in complex cases.
The Collateral Source Rule Advantage
Missouri law prohibits insurers from reducing your claim because:
Health insurance paid some bills
You received disability payments
Family helped with expenses
This rule can significantly increase net recovery.
Comparative Fault Complications
Missouri's pure comparative fault system means:
Even if 99% at fault, you can recover 1%
Juries must be carefully instructed on allocation
Multiple defendants will blame each other
The Importance of Documentation
Every damage category requires:
Dated receipts
Physician narratives
Employer verification
Photographic evidence
Disorganization is the enemy of full compensation.
Why Settlement Timing Matters
Accepting an offer too early means losing rights to:
Future surgeries
Later-discovered conditions
Ongoing pain management
Most St. Louis attorneys recommend waiting until Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI).
The Jury Psychology Factor
St. Louis City juries tend to award:
Higher amounts for visible injuries
More for sympathetic plaintiffs
Less for perceived contributory negligence
Case presentation must account for these tendencies.
From the initial crash to the final settlement check, every decision impacts your total recovery. St. Louis victims who understand these damage categories routinely secure 3-5x more than those who accept insurer first offers. The path to full compensation isn't just about proving fault—it's about meticulously documenting how the accident changed every aspect of your life. With Missouri's 5-year statute of limitations, you have time to build the right case, but evidence fades fast. The question isn't just "what can I recover?"—it's "what will I lose if I don't fight for everything owed?"
Latest posts in our blog
Be the first to read what's new!
Missouri license plate laws are governed by Chapter 301 of the Missouri Revised Statutes, which outlines registration requirements, plate display rules, and penalties for noncompliance. Vehicle owners must ensure their plates are properly secured, visible, and unobstructed at all times to avoid legal consequences. The law specifies that plates must...
St. Louis, with its patchwork of historic neighborhoods, bustling downtown corridors, and sprawling suburban connectors, presents a complex landscape for pedestrian safety. While the city's walkability is often touted as a strength, certain areas consistently emerge as hotspots for accidents, blending urban design flaws with socioeconomic factors....
The legal doctrine of constructive notice operates as a powerful fiction—it presumes knowledge of certain facts, even when no actual awareness exists, based on the principle that some information is so readily available that a person should have known it. Unlike actual notice, which requires direct communication or conscious awareness,...